How New Leaders Can Build Confidence: 5 Strategies
One behind-the-scenes consequence of the pandemic was the number of seasoned leaders who left the corporate world. Whether they were surprised by it with layoffs, guided toward it with early retirement or chose it of their own volition, the departure of seasoned leaders created a wide gap and broad opportunities for new leaders to step up.
It has brought new energy and fresh ideas to the leadership table…as well as some unexpected risks. In most companies, it was an intentional choice and an understood risk to pull forward less experienced leaders. And what we’re now seeing that companies didn’t consider was that the lack of experience could lead to a lack of confidence, which is paralyzing to a leader.
Here’s an example of the conversation that we’ve had with hundreds of these new leaders:
“In the last year, I moved up two levels and now run a region for our company. It has been an incredible opportunity for me and one that I didn’t expect to get for another five years. I’ve settled in with the five teams that now report to me, and we have begun to build a new way of working together. It was going smoothly until I dealt with a manufacturing delay. It happened a week before our senior leadership meeting where I planned to talk about the delay and ask for ideas for solving it. And that was a rookie mistake!
In less than five minutes, it was clear this was not the place to talk through “my” issue. The manufacturing delay, while not my fault, was my responsibility and no one in that room wanted to solve it with me. I felt foolish for bringing it up and embarrassed that I didn’t know how to resolve it.
And that’s when I realized the difference between me and the peers in the room was experience. I lost my confidence in that first meeting, and I’ve been trying to get it back ever since.”
Why Newly Promoted Leaders Often Struggle With Confidence
For many leaders, confidence comes with experience. Every situation isn’t the same, but years of experience builds a repertoire of managing conflicts and bringing enough gravitas to discussions to drive toward a resolution. That isn’t easy if your repertoire is a few specific experiences vs. years of on-the-job training.
And it’s magnified by two other dynamics:
First, many corporate cultures feel “training” ends when someone reaches a director level. So, new leaders aren’t likely to feel comfortable seeking traditional training to strengthen their skills. And in many companies, it doesn’t even exist at the right level with the right focus.
Second, when these leaders were managers, they talked openly about uncertainty with their teams. They got kudos for being open and authentic. That has risks for a leader. It’s one thing for employees to know a manager isn’t sure; it’s a very different feeling for employees when they know a leader is unsure.
And that’s why new leaders, and the leadership development teams who support them, are looking for new ways to strengthen personal confidence and expand executive learning.
There is an accelerated way to build confidence, but it requires a new leader to have good resources and make good choices in five key areas.
Here’s how we guide a new leader through the choices:
1. Reset Your Expectations as a New Leader
It may seem contrite, but many new leaders think about their roles as the next step beyond a seasoned manager. It’s not. It’s a big leap. When we engage with a leader, a common question is “Why does communication matter so much now? I’ve always had pretty good success influencing groups to date.” Well, expectations go up overnight. “Pretty good “ on a manager is “not good enough” on a leader.
2. Identify and Brand Your Leadership Superpower
While you may not have the experience of your peers, you do bring new thinking to a leadership team. Make sure this shows up quickly among your new peer group. Leaders are rarely subject matter experts. Instead, they bring a superpower that most companies are counting on to accelerate results and find new opportunities.
3. Build a Leadership Feedback Loop
As a new leader, you need to know your blind spots, and you need real-time insight on where you aren’t having impact. No one is going to tell you. It’s risky to give a leader feedback, and even if you get honest input from a few, you’re relying on them to represent the perspective of a large group. Add a feedback loop into the communication process you put in place. Make it easy and safe for employees to provide feedback and reaction.
4. Identify Your Leadership Skill Gaps
As I mentioned, you may not “learn” what you need to know in the traditional training format. That’s OK; you can find other ways and resources to continue to build out your skill set. But recognize that you need to continue to build it out. We help new leaders build a development plan that includes a blend of training for specific tools and 1:1 coaching for personal guidance.
5. Create a Strong Leadership Support System
While it gets harder to ask for “help” internally, you can find a lot of support among peers in similar functions outside your company. Whether you get to a peer group through an industry cohort or you build your own cohort less formally, there are peers who are also settling into accelerated careers. A good sounding board and shared experiences builds trust and support quickly.
The concept of accelerating leaders has brought some unexpected gaps within organizations. But the gaps don’t have to widen. In fact, the steps above can narrow the gap quickly. There is unlimited opportunity for today’s new leaders; they just need a little help jumping in with momentum. Today’s leaders will gain experience in new and different ways, and it’s a topic we’re passionate about.
How Communication Changes During a Leadership Transition
A newly promoted leader is not simply doing a larger version of the previous job. The audience changes, the stakes increase and communication becomes a much greater part of how the leader’s effectiveness is evaluated.
At the manager level, communication may focus on assigning work, supporting employees and keeping projects moving. At the leadership level, the conversation expands. Leaders must explain business priorities, influence peers, communicate across functions and create confidence when the path forward is not completely clear.
That requires a different level of preparation.
New leaders often know more detail than anyone else in the room. But senior audiences rarely need all of that detail. They need the leader to identify the issue, explain its business impact, recommend a direction and clarify the decision or support needed.
The shift is from reporting information to providing leadership.
Turn Uncertainty into a Leadership Position
New leaders sometimes believe they must have every answer before speaking with senior colleagues. That expectation creates unnecessary pressure and can make uncertainty feel like a weakness.
Experienced leaders do not always have the answer either. The difference is often how they frame the situation.
Instead of bringing an unresolved problem into the room, a prepared leader can communicate:
- What has happened
- Why it matters
- What is already known
- What remains uncertain
- Which options have been considered
- What the leader recommends
- What decision or support is needed
This structure does not hide uncertainty. It puts the uncertainty into context and demonstrates that the leader has taken ownership of the issue.
Confidence does not require pretending to know more than you do. It requires showing that you can assess the situation, make a thoughtful recommendation and guide the conversation toward action.
Build a 90-Day Leadership Communication Plan
A leadership transition plan often focuses on business priorities, stakeholders and early results. It should also include communication goals.
During the first 90 days, newly promoted leaders should identify the situations that will shape how others experience them. Those situations may include executive meetings, team updates, strategic recommendations, difficult conversations and interactions with new peers.
For each situation, consider Content, Style and Situation.
- Content: What does this audience need to understand, remember or do?
- Style: What communication choices will reinforce confidence, clarity and credibility?
- Situation: What expectations, relationships and business pressures could affect how the message is received?
The leader can then identify one or two behaviors to practice. The goal might be stating the recommendation earlier, reducing unnecessary detail, listening longer before responding or maintaining composure when challenged.
A focused plan gives a new leader something more useful than the broad instruction to “be more confident.” It creates specific behaviors that can be practiced, observed and strengthened.
Give New Leaders Room to Learn
Organizations also have a role in reducing the risks of accelerated leadership.
A promotion may recognize potential, but it does not instantly provide the experiences the leader would otherwise have developed over several years. New leaders need access to feedback, experienced perspective and confidential guidance as they encounter unfamiliar situations.
That support might include:
- Executive coaching connected to real business priorities
- Peer cohorts for leaders at similar career stages
- Communication training for high-stakes conversations
- Regular feedback from managers and key stakeholders
- Opportunities to observe experienced executives
- Structured reflection after important meetings or decisions
- Clear expectations for the new role
This is not remedial development. It is a practical investment in helping capable leaders adjust to a larger scope of responsibility.
Confidence Grows Through Prepared Experience
There is no shortcut that replaces experience. But organizations can help new leaders gain the right experience more intentionally.
Every executive conversation, difficult decision and unexpected challenge can expand a leader’s repertoire. The key is making sure the leader reflects on the experience rather than simply moving to the next demand.
What worked? Where did the conversation lose momentum? What did the audience need that the leader did not provide? What should happen differently next time?
Those questions turn an uncomfortable moment into useful development.
New leaders do not need to avoid every mistake. They need a process for learning from mistakes without allowing one difficult experience to define their confidence.
SW&A helps newly promoted and accelerated leaders build the communication skills required at higher levels of leadership. Through executive coaching and tailored leadership communication programs, leaders prepare for real situations, strengthen their executive presence and develop the confidence to communicate with clarity and impact.
The opportunity to step into leadership may arrive earlier than expected. The communication skills, feedback and support surrounding that transition can determine whether a leader simply enters the role or grows into it.
If you’re a new leader or you’re trying to help a group of new leaders build confidence, we’d like to share more about our approach.
Call us when you need us!
Also Read: Strengthening the Impact of Leadership Teams
Talk to Us About What’s Right for You → | Explore Tailored Programs → | LinkedIn →

